Welcome to Software Observatory Etherpad!

This pad text is synchronized as you type, so that everyone viewing this page sees the same text.

To prevent this pad from appearing in the etherdump, paste (or leave) the following code:

__NOPUBLISH__

.
Warning: DirtyDB is used. This is fine for testing but not recommended for production. -- To suppress these warning messages change suppressErrorsInPadText to true in your settings.json
BECOMING SOFTWARE

Some boundaries that appear to be fuzzy when we try to define them (appeared wed. // thurs.):
- fuzzy line between data and software
- fuzzy line between software and hardware
- tollerance to noise, software being less tollerant to changes. That was something that could define software from data.
- fuzzy line between software and signal (signal vs. noise)
- machine learning algorithm and the training data, adaptibility
- developer/
- forking (when does one software becomes another software?)
- Is a social network a piece of software?
- FPGAs and Hardware Definition Languages

(FRIDAY)
- labor (is trainining an ML machine labor? "the reCATCHPA insight")
- process (Agile practices) "using" your users to define the requirements of the product (features in the product become defined by the feedback of the release cycle)
- services and agile processes collapsing the divide between production and  use
- Agile methodologies collapse product, labor and process.
- there is also the pain and labor that users bring to software that is rarely documented (e.g., activists using Signal) 

• - comment based on a study of floss chat tools (secure messaging?)

- thin / fat client software, where does it live?
- poc or gtf o    pdf is an executable is an image / http:// alchemistowl.org/pocorgtfo

Appying agile: agile refers to a set of practices, a number of which needs to be adopted to qualify as an agile process.

Political Economy of Software Engineering 

• - software engineering is an expensive process
• - Tom DeMarco: why does software cost so much? It mostly has to do with process.
• - study of linux kernel: how much did it cost? 
• compensated through economies of scale
• - web development changed the landscape
• - more people joined the bandwagon: ex-yugoslavia a place where development gets outsourced to, also Russia and India (all hackers are Russian now, too)
• - when you establish a relationship of outsourcing
• 
  

- objective is not to define what is software, 

• - describe the how of software becoming
• - discussing "what is software" is productive, worth elaborating
• writing software does not come with the kind of reflection that this discussion provides

- it seemed obvious what is software, but it became more difficult

• - interest in corner cases: popular encryption algorithms, AES: you can write a program implementing it: software. but now it is embeddded in the chip, hardware.
• - code sequences in pdf: nobody would consider pdf to be software
• - postscript can also do this
• - proof of concept (gtfo) you can read it and execute it (peter will add a link)
• - burnt out ruby developer: he retired all the software and manuals. he published a file with a printing queue,
• - corner cases: narrow down the whole thing, we cannot come up with a definition of software, we can think about to come up with a feature set
• -if these features are fulfilled it can be considered software
• - yesterday: fpga: reconfigulrable hardware 
• Jean: what is software? he said, i can only tell you what is good software. qualifiers that can help narrow down the path: queer software  

- methodology: we can apply extreme programming as a way to write together (XP ==> programming in pairs or doing extensive code review, unit testing of all code)

• take a topic, ask people and document in twos
• 
  

- yesterday we had these machines with different use, with the punch cards

• looking at how the were used in business use
• mixed with what martino and anita showed: binaries as sets of instructions
• could we develop other algorithms with these machines
• do an addition or hangman on the tabulation machine
• what could be this sequence with the operator that handles the cards
• user, developer, operator, tester, sufferer, translator, technical writer, marketer, manager, product owner, devops etc.
• 
  

- software engineering practices are spreading -> a managerial culture that is poisoning other practices...

• it has effected start-up culture and how capital gets invested
• the individual genuis: the falsehood around the garage kids
• the idea with rushing to the market: minimum viable product. pervasive today
• grasshoper: data flow design tool
• architects are using it and are actually building software
• urban systems: generative system, they work mostly in china
• software with  sliders, their entire design process is building sotware so that you can design cities but moving the sliders
• the idea of a star architect, discussed in media, there is a much less glamorous process of building hopsitals, staidums
• configurable and modular cities
• 
  
• - architects see themselves as the original system architects and design
• BIM: every toilette is set up, the idea that you can have a process of when the toilette was built and fixed and replaced. the small guys are doing this 
• 
  

- roles and labor relations very interesting

• - a joke: bastardization of the agile method as a self-help method
• - i want to understand how software is made and services etc.
• - seeing it also as a vessel for having fun
• it is expensive, industry, investment
• maybe there is a way to misuse it
• make little steps that makes it funny, stupid or real
• relating also to what silvio was presenting 
• there is a link between the method and the output that we see as software
• in which way? i want to figure it out more...
• everybody is a start-up: bad metaphors

• 
  

cargocult: by richard feynman         

• rituals that people look at        
• colonialist practice?          
• in polynesia: pacific islands that were occupied by americans         
• the planes used to bring cargo, wealth         
• so they built an airport out of wood and stuff that was laying around hoping that the planes would come back
• by replicating the form hoping that things will materialize
• peolpe being occupied, with no relationship with them
• that's maybe what you are referring to
• a metaphor in coputing: cargocult
• i don't know if this actually happened
• this came after feynman published an article that was called cargocult science
• just by following the formal aspects of scientific method, people expect their results to be scientific
• i am not sure if it happened due to something that happened in polynesia
• or because of feynman's storytelling
• burning man: cargocult
• 
  

- why did you think about cargo cult?

• somehow as an image: interpreting agile practices as something different
• misusing of it
• taking at face value
• getting blind to some of the metaphors
• 
  
• doing it a bit more fun and playful
• this could be misused as a methodology to understand agile processes
• stripping the agile methodology some of its aspects and putting some of it back
• some of those words: if you look at them
• scrum i don't know well but it refers to rugby
• 
  
• idea: to look at the origins of terms in agile methods, like scrum
• take a scrum metaphor and insert yoga into it what happens?
• agile scrum yoga
• agile yoga is a thing
• 
  

- what this guide would be

• if it is about providing people with guidance on how to observer
•         data vs. software
•         software vs. hardware
•         to be interesting guidance
•         expand upon making these distinctions
•         
•         some of the programs we are having in making a distinction between software and everything else is
•         using information system
•         if you are using several pieces of software
•         then the things they do between using different software becomes the most important glue that makes sense of the software
•         one way you can understand this is seeing software as automating practice
•         and look at some workflows of people using software
•         if data and software is a thing, isn't it reasonable to map this out as an information system
•         data coming, breaking down the function
• 
  

- cargocult: mistakes, can you see something where you don't see the infrastructure but just the gesture, people on the radio are talking with someone else

• saying we don't have any more milk, drop us some
• i am unhappy about the term: the balance of power the occupied and the occupier
• the occupier made a mistake
• cargocult you don;t understand the infrastructre and try to make sense
• it is great mistakes
• 
  

- unrelated

• relationship between observation and evaluation
• from what i gather: evaluation is a core element of the agile method
• in order to be able to review and adapt to the moving target
• this observation and evaluation: evaluation is not only observation, it is something plus some criteria
• to have some criteria: in the sense of the cargocult, what they replicate is what they see, an image
•         

what are these things:

framing device: data vs. software, the roles (a taxonomy device) -- relates to identfifying obvious and less obvious forms of labor
cargocult: method of observation


META THINKING:

asking what is software as a method?

terms relevant to describing software:

•     computing
• programming
• developing
• programming languages
• algorithms
• data...
• development processes
• roles
• architecture
• protocols
• 
  

what are the economic forces acting upon software?

• how do you find out?
• 
  

CARGOCULT PROPS:

•     - coconut shells
• - cardboard laptops
• - candy wrappers
• - chewin gum as stickies
• - code reviews

A qualifier like "good", "bad", "spy", "queer", "proletarian", "bourgeisoie" can help narrow down definitions.

What is not software?